Are We Accidentally Killing Off the Private Landlord?

There's something rather peculiar happening in Britain's rental market. We have a chronic shortage of housing, an increasingly complicated regulatory landscape and a political conversation that frequently treats private landlords as though they're personally responsible for every problem the country has ever had with renting. Meanwhile, we're steadily making it harder for those same landlords to justify providing homes in the first place.

I'm not suggesting landlords should be exempt from regulation, that tenants shouldn't enjoy meaningful protections or that housing should be treated purely as an investment opportunity. Quite the opposite. I've spent more than two decades working in residential property, and I firmly believe that professional standards and fair treatment are fundamental to a healthy rental market. But I do think we need to have a rather more grown-up conversation about what happens when the financial and operational realities of providing rental housing stop making sense.

Because I'm increasingly concerned that the outcome of our current approach might look very different from the one politicians and campaigners are hoping to achieve. And some of the evidence for that concern is coming from rather closer to home than I'd like.

The Landlord Everyone Loves to Hate

I recently sat down with Nitin Agarwal, founder of Property Deal Insights, for an episode of The Viking Chats. Nitin has an interesting perspective because he approaches the housing market from several directions. He's a technology entrepreneur, a property investor and someone whose business works with estate agents, lenders and increasingly large institutional property operators.

Our conversation eventually turned towards the changing ownership of Britain's rental housing, and it raised a question I've been thinking about for some time. Why are we so uncomfortable with an individual making money from providing rental housing, yet apparently much more relaxed about a large corporation doing precisely the same thing?

Of course, there are good landlords and bad landlords. There are responsible institutional operators and undoubtedly examples of corporate landlords falling short too. Ownership structure doesn't automatically determine the quality of someone's behaviour, but the public conversation often seems to treat the individual landlord as a fundamentally suspicious character, while institutional investment is discussed as though it represents the natural modernisation of the sector.

I'm not entirely convinced we've thought through what that transition might mean. Particularly when you consider how many of the changes we're making to the rental market appear to favour businesses with greater financial resources, larger portfolios and the ability to spread their costs across hundreds or thousands of properties.

The Economics Have Changed, Whether We Like It or Not

For a long time, residential property investment in London enjoyed a fairly extraordinary advantage. Capital values were rising strongly enough that many investors could afford to be relatively relaxed about the income their properties generated. If the property was increasing substantially in value over time, a modest rental yield wasn't necessarily a problem, because the long-term investment case was largely built around capital appreciation.

That environment has changed. London's property market is considerably more complicated today, with higher borrowing costs, taxation, maintenance expenditure, regulatory obligations and pressure on capital values altering the calculations for many landlords. Leasehold flats present their own additional difficulties, particularly where service charges, building safety concerns and uncertainty around future liabilities affect both saleability and investment performance.

The result is that landlords increasingly need their properties to work as actual income-producing investments. For some, the figures are becoming distinctly uncomfortable, particularly where properties were purchased years ago in personal names under a very different tax framework. Those landlords didn't necessarily make irresponsible decisions. They made decisions based on the rules and expectations that existed at the time, only to find that the financial landscape surrounding those investments had changed considerably.

Unlike somebody deciding whether to buy an investment property today, an existing landlord can't always restructure their ownership without substantial costs. It's remarkably easy to tell somebody to change their investment strategy when you're not the person facing the tax bill, and I think that distinction is frequently overlooked in the wider conversation about private landlords.

Two Landlords Who Chose to Leave Their Properties Empty

During the conversation with Nitin, I shared something that happened at Base this year. Two landlords, both of whom we've worked with for around fifteen or sixteen years, reached the end of their respective tenancies and made an unusual decision. They weren't going to find replacement tenants, but they weren't going to sell their properties either.

Instead, they decided to leave them empty. These weren't landlords who'd suddenly lost faith in us, had dreadful experiences with their tenants or decided that London property was a terrible investment. Their decisions were driven by the financial calculations, which suggested that the difference between continuing to rent the properties and leaving them vacant was negligible once the relevant costs and tax implications were considered.

So they chose to remove the hassle. No more maintenance associated with tenants, no more wear and tear, no more tenancy management and, importantly, no more exposure to some of the risks and obligations that come with being a landlord. Both also had a practical use for the properties, regularly visiting London for work or social reasons and deciding the flats could become somewhere to stay rather than investments generating rental income.

Now, I'm not suggesting this is a widespread national trend. Two examples from our own portfolio certainly don't establish that, and it would be irresponsible to pretend otherwise. But they illustrate a rather uncomfortable possibility: what happens when the economics of renting a property become so unattractive that an owner decides they'd rather leave it empty?

The property hasn't disappeared, and the owner hasn't necessarily suffered a catastrophic financial loss. But a home that was previously available to a tenant is no longer part of the rental market. That's a pretty lousy outcome for a country that desperately needs more housing, and one we should be paying considerably more attention to.

The Law of Unintended Consequences

One of my biggest frustrations with housing policy is the tendency to focus almost exclusively on the intended benefits of a particular change. If you're campaigning for stronger tenant protections, you're naturally going to emphasise the people who could benefit. If you're a politician proposing new rules, you're going to talk about the improvements you hope those rules will deliver. That's understandable, but housing is an extraordinarily interconnected system, and changing one part of it rarely leaves everything else untouched.

Take the Renters' Rights reforms. There are provisions that I support in principle, and there are others where I think the practical implications deserve much closer examination. What concerns me is the tendency to frame these changes as though they can only produce positive outcomes for tenants, when the reality is that different tenants have different needs and circumstances.

At Base, we had tenants who specifically negotiated longer fixed-term agreements because they wanted certainty around their children's schooling or a particular employment commitment. That arrangement suited them, but changes to the tenancy framework meant the contractual structure they had deliberately chosen was no longer available in the same form. The intention behind greater flexibility and protection may be perfectly reasonable, yet that doesn't mean every individual tenant will experience the change as an improvement.

The same principle applies to rent bidding restrictions. Preventing tenants from being pressured into offering more than the advertised rent sounds attractive, but if an agent knows they cannot accept a higher offer, there's an obvious incentive to advertise at a more ambitious asking price in the first place. Whether that becomes a widespread market response remains to be seen, but it's exactly the sort of behavioural consequence that should be considered before we declare a policy an unqualified success.

Good intentions are important, but they don't guarantee good outcomes. And when we're talking about something as fundamental as people's homes, I think we have a responsibility to examine both sides of that equation rather than simply congratulating ourselves for introducing another well-meaning reform.

Are We Creating a Rental Market That Only Big Businesses Can Afford to Operate In?

Nitin described how Property Deal Insights is increasingly working with institutional investors and operators who want sophisticated data to assess potential acquisitions across the country. These businesses can examine large numbers of properties, compare investment opportunities and make decisions using detailed financial and property information. That's a very different approach from somebody who owns one or two flats and manages their investment alongside a separate career.

And there's nothing inherently wrong with it. Large professional operators can bring substantial advantages to the rental market, investing in systems, standardising processes, developing specialist teams and managing compliance across sizeable portfolios. They can also make decisions with less emotional attachment to an individual property, which can be a positive thing when it comes to maintenance and management.

If a maintenance issue meets the relevant criteria, the instruction can simply be to get it fixed. That's potentially a very positive experience for residents, particularly when compared with a landlord who might hesitate because they remember paying for the same work a few years earlier. But there is another side to the equation, and it's one that becomes increasingly important as the cost of operating in the sector rises.

Larger businesses can spread fixed costs across many more properties. They have access to professional advice, technology and operational structures that smaller landlords may struggle to justify. As regulation becomes more complex and compliance more demanding, those advantages become increasingly important, particularly when combined with the tax considerations, financing pressures and administrative burden facing smaller investors.

It's not difficult to imagine a market that becomes progressively more concentrated, with fewer landlords controlling larger portfolios and an increasing proportion of rental housing held through corporate structures. Perhaps that's where we're heading, but we should be careful about assuming it's automatically better simply because it looks more professional.

Corporate Landlords Still Want to Make Money

Here's the bit that I find particularly strange. Some of the strongest criticism of private landlords centres on the idea that housing shouldn't be something people profit from. Yet the alternative increasingly being encouraged is institutional investment, and institutional investors are, unsurprisingly, rather interested in making money.

They have investors to satisfy, returns to generate and financial performance to manage. That doesn't make them bad landlords, but it does make the suggestion that corporate ownership somehow removes the profit motive rather difficult to take seriously. A large property company isn't providing housing as an act of charity. It's investing capital in the expectation of generating an appropriate return, just like an individual landlord.

The difference lies in the scale, structure and way the business operates. Those distinctions matter, but they don't magically eliminate the underlying commercial realities. And I think we need a rental market that allows different types of responsible providers to coexist, rather than one that gradually makes participation unviable for everyone except the largest organisations.

There is room for institutional build-to-rent developments, professionally managed portfolios and individual landlords who own a small number of properties. The question should be whether those homes are safe, well maintained, fairly managed and available at prices the market can sustain, rather than whether the person receiving the rent happens to be an individual or a corporation.

We Need to Stop Frightening Landlords Out of the Market

There's another uncomfortable issue here, and it's one where I think estate agents need to accept some responsibility. Over the past couple of years, I've been surprised by the amount of frankly hysterical commentary coming from parts of our own industry about rental reform. Every proposed change becomes the end of the private rented sector, and every new obligation is presented as the final nail in the landlord's coffin.

Then some of those same agents seem astonished when their landlords decide they've had enough. Well, what did you expect? If you're the trusted professional somebody relies upon to manage their investment, and you spend months telling them the entire market is about to collapse, don't be terribly surprised when they start looking for the exit.

That's not to say agents should conceal genuine risks or pretend difficult changes are wonderful. Quite the opposite. Our job is to explain what is changing, what it means for an individual landlord and what practical steps they can take. There is an enormous difference between giving somebody a balanced assessment of their options and repeatedly telling them that everything is on fire.

Professional advice should help people make informed decisions rather than create unnecessary panic. And when we're already dealing with a shortage of available rental homes, that distinction matters enormously. Agents have a responsibility to communicate with care, particularly when their words can influence decisions about whether homes remain available to rent.

The Future Might Be Bigger. That Doesn't Mean It Will Be Better.

I suspect the next decade will bring substantial changes to the ownership and management of rental housing. Technology, regulation, financing and the growing involvement of institutional capital are all pushing the market towards greater scale and professionalisation. Some of that will be positive, and better information, stronger operational systems and more consistent management standards are developments I'd welcome.

But I don't think we should confuse consolidation with progress. A rental market dominated by fewer, larger operators might be more efficient in some respects, but it could also reduce the diversity of housing providers, concentrate commercial influence and make the market less accessible to smaller investors. We don't yet know precisely how that balance will play out, and it's worth resisting the temptation to assume that every structural change represents an improvement.

What I do know is that housing policy needs to be judged by the homes it actually makes available, the standards those homes meet and the experience of the people living in them. If we introduce reforms intended to improve renting, but the combined financial and operational consequences persuade responsible landlords to withdraw properties from the market, we need to be willing to acknowledge that. If tenants gain additional rights but find themselves competing for fewer available homes, that deserves serious examination too.

And if the result is a market where only increasingly large corporate structures can operate comfortably, we should at least be having an honest conversation about whether that's the outcome we intended. Because the real objective shouldn't be to make life difficult for landlords or to make life easy for them. It should be to create a rental market that works for tenants, responsible landlords and the long-term health of our housing supply.

That's a rather more complicated ambition than another headline-grabbing policy announcement, but it's one worth getting right. And if we genuinely care about the future of renting, perhaps it's time we started paying as much attention to the consequences of our decisions as we do to the intentions behind them.

‍